Probably yes for the spectacles themselves, but not as a blanket rule. HPCSA Booklet 19 says registered practitioners may not charge fees for services not yet rendered, with exceptions that include medical aid co-payments and "custom made medical devices which cannot be used or supplied to another patient". Lenses made up to one patient's prescription appear to fit that exception. The eye examination does not, and the patient must know your fees, in writing, before you start.
Deposits on glasses are common in South African optometry, and most patients expect them. The point of this guide is to make sure your policy rests on the actual wording, not habit.
This is a plain-language summary of HPCSA guidance, not legal advice. Confirm your own policy with the HPCSA, your professional association or your indemnity provider.
Why HPCSA billing guidance applies
Optometrists and dispensing opticians are registered with the Health Professions Council of South Africa, so their billing falls under HPCSA ethical guidance. The HPCSA and the South African Optometric Association underlined in December 2024 that prescription spectacles and contact lenses should come from registered practitioners after a proper examination (HPCSA and SAOA statement, 2024). Being a regulated health service brings regulated billing with it.
The relevant document is Booklet 19, Guidelines on matters relating to ethical billing practices, published in June 2024.
What Booklet 19 says about advance payment
Section 12 reads:
Health practitioner shall not charge fees for health services not yet rendered, except for costs of prostheses, co-payment at medical aid rates required from patient or it is a foreign patient requiring health services in South Africa, or it is for custom made medical devices which cannot be used or supplied to another patient, or modified for another patient who requires a similar device to recover the cost incurred by the health practitioner.
Applied to a typical optometry visit:
| Item | Advance payment under s12? | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Eye examination | No | A professional service, charged when rendered |
| Lenses made to the patient's prescription | Appears to qualify | Custom-made for one patient and cannot be supplied to another |
| Frame from stock | Unclear | It can be sold to someone else until it is glazed |
| Medical aid co-payment | Yes | Listed exception, at medical aid rates |
| Foreign patient | Yes | Listed exception |
The exception is worded around recovering "the cost incurred by the health practitioner". A deposit that roughly covers the lens and laboratory costs sits most comfortably inside that wording. A deposit far above your costs is harder to defend.
Tell the patient first, in writing
Before any deposit, the patient must know the price. Section 53 of the Health Professions Act, quoted in Booklet 19, requires practitioners to tell patients the fee before rendering a service when the patient asks, or when it exceeds the usual fee. Booklet 19 then goes further:
- patients must be aware of fees "prior to the commencement of any fee generating activities"
- patients on medical aid must be told how your fees affect what they can claim
- informed financial consent must be obtained in writing
- quotations and invoices can form part of that record
In practice, the dispensing quote is your informed financial consent document. Show the frame, lenses, coatings and examination fee separately, the expected medical aid portion, the patient's share, the deposit and when the balance is due. Have the patient sign it.
Payment plans
Booklet 19 allows payment arrangements with written consent and says such an arrangement "should not be perceived as a credit agreement". It also says practitioners may not charge interest on accrued debt, citing the National Credit Act, with one narrow exception where the patient has not paid and the medical aid has also rejected the claim. If you offer instalments, keep them interest-free and in writing.
When the balance is not paid
Two rules shape what you can do:
- You may not hold back results. Booklet 19 says practitioners may not withhold or withdraw the outcomes of treatment or investigations because of non-payment, and encourages legal debt collection instead.
- Reasonable attempts come first. It says practitioners should make reasonable attempts to engage the patient before formal debt collection.
Reasonable attempts means reminders, sent consistently, with an easy way to pay. Remi's PaidUp invoice chasing (R299 a month) handles that follow-up with polite reminders and a payment link, so your team is not making awkward calls between examinations.
A deposit policy checklist
- Deposits apply to custom-made items, not to the examination.
- The amount is linked to your real costs for that order.
- The patient sees and signs a written quote before paying.
- The quote states what happens to the deposit if the order is cancelled after lenses are made.
- Instalment plans are in writing and interest-free.
- Unpaid balances are followed up on a set schedule before any handover to collections.
- Examination results are never held back over an unpaid account.
Where the phone fits
Questions about deposits and payment plans often come by phone: "Do I have to pay upfront?", "Can I pay it off?", "Are my glasses ready?". Answering them the same way every time, including after hours, prevents most disputes. An AI receptionist for optometrists can answer the line around the clock, give callers the policy you have agreed, book appointments and send a payment link when you use them. Remi never gives clinical advice, and puts urgent eye problems through to the person you choose.
The short version
- Booklet 19 restricts advance fees, but lists custom-made devices and medical aid co-payments as exceptions.
- Lenses made to a patient's prescription appear to qualify. The eye examination does not.
- Keep deposits close to your actual costs, and put the quote, deposit and refund terms in writing first.
- Payment plans need written consent and no interest.
- Never hold back examination results over non-payment. Follow up reasonably, then use legal collection.